▼

Historic Encinitas La Paloma Theatre Faces Uncertain Future Amid Claims Of Sale To Church

A grassroots campaign to save Encinitas' nearly century-old La Paloma Theatre has emerged following claims that the historic movie house is in escrow to a buyer who intends to convert the property into a church and community center, raising questions about the future of one of San Diego County's last remaining single-screen cinemas.

A Change.org petition launched Saturday, November 14, titled "Save the La Paloma Theater from redevelopment!", alleges that plans are underway to sell the historic property at 471 South Coast Highway 101 and convert it to religious and community uses. The petition calls on local officials and community members to intervene before Encinitas loses a cultural institution that has operated since 1928.

The alleged sale has not been independently confirmed. No buyer has been publicly identified, no purchase price or closing date has been disclosed, and neither the theater's longtime operator nor a prospective purchaser has publicly announced a transaction.

The petition was created by Tyler Blevins, who describes himself as "just a guy who loves this old cinema and wants to do what he can to help it." Blevins says he learned of the potential sale from the theater's operators, who allegedly told him that the building is currently in escrow.

According to Blevins, the theater rents its auditorium to a church congregation, and someone associated with that group is seeking to purchase the property, which also contains other commercial businesses, including a music store and bar. He claims the prospective buyer intends to remodel the property into a church and community center.

Blevins further states that La Paloma's existing lease extends through October 2027, potentially allowing the theater to continue operating for approximately another year even if the building changes ownership.

These details remain unverified and are based on Blevins' account of conversations with theater personnel. No purchase agreement, escrow documentation or other evidence establishing an impending sale has been made public.

The petition was accompanied by the launch of an Instagram account, @savelapalomatheatre, which warns that the theater's 98-year history is in jeopardy. As of early Sunday morning, the petition had attracted approximately 20 signatures, with a stated initial goal of 25.

One church with an established presence at La Paloma is Light Church, a Christian congregation that has held Sunday services inside the theater since 2021. According to the church's website, services currently take place at La Paloma at 9 and 11am, with additional gatherings at its chapel at 831 Third Street in Encinitas.

The church's use of the theater is longstanding and publicly documented. However, there is no publicly available evidence identifying Light Church, its leadership or any affiliated individual as the prospective purchaser. The congregation has not publicly announced plans to acquire La Paloma.

The possibility of a sale is particularly significant because the theater's longtime operator does not appear to own the underlying real estate.

Allen Largent, who began working at La Paloma as a teenage projectionist in 1979 and took over the theater business in 1992, has spent decades maintaining the property as an independent movie house. Previous reporting has distinguished ownership of the theater business from ownership of the building itself.

A 2016 report by The Coast News identified Santa Monica-based Lico Realty & Management Company as the property owner at the time. More recent property information lists a tax mailing address at 3304 Pico Boulevard in Santa Monica, consistent with the property's historical ties to an out-of-town owner. However, the current titleholder and any pending transaction have not been independently verified.

The distinction between ownership of the real estate and operation of the cinema is central to understanding the situation. If the building is owned separately from the theater business, a property sale could proceed without Largent selling the business itself, although the theater's long-term future could depend on the terms of its lease and the intentions of a new landlord.

The reported plans also contrast with Largent's previously stated vision for La Paloma.

For years, he has advocated preserving the theater's original single-screen configuration rather than dividing the auditorium or converting it to another use. During earlier discussions about restoration, Largent described his goal as preserving, restoring and protecting the historic property.

In a 2025 San Diego Union-Tribune feature, Largent discussed efforts to secure renovation assistance and establish a nonprofit organization that could eventually assume responsibility for preserving the theater. The effort was intended to ensure that La Paloma could continue operating as a cinema after his retirement.

The building's preservation has also been a longstanding concern for the City of Encinitas.

La Paloma is included in the city's Register of Historic Places, and a historical evaluation determined that the property qualifies as a historical resource under the California Environmental Quality Act. The building has also been found eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places and California Register of Historical Resources, although eligibility does not necessarily mean formal listing on either register.

The Downtown Encinitas Specific Plan specifically identifies preservation of La Paloma as a community planning objective. The property is located within the D-CM-1 commercial mixed-use zone, where religious institutions are subject to a minor use permit requirement.

Consequently, a change in ownership would not automatically authorize conversion of the theater into a permanent religious institution or substantial alterations to the historic building. Depending on the scope of any proposed project, additional city approvals and historic-resource review could be required.

No publicly identified application to convert La Paloma into a church has surfaced. The city's November 5 Planning Commission agenda and November 18 City Council agenda contain no item concerning such a conversion, although the absence of an agenda item does not establish that no preliminary discussions or applications exist.

The potential loss of La Paloma would represent a significant change to downtown Encinitas, where the theater has stood at the corner of Coast Highway 101 and D Street for nearly a century.

La Paloma opened on February 11, 1928, with a screening of The Cohens and Kellys in Paris. The Spanish Revival-style theater was among the region's early movie houses equipped for talking pictures, and its original auditorium also accommodated live entertainment and silent-film presentations accompanied by a pipe organ.

Over the decades, the venue became closely associated with Southern California surf culture, screening surf films and documentaries while serving as a gathering place for generations of Encinitas residents. Its stage has hosted performers including Jerry Garcia, Eddie Vedder, Nickel Creek and Loreena McKennitt.

Today, La Paloma continues operating as an independent cinema and event venue, offering contemporary films, specialty screenings, surf documentaries and live performances. Its longstanding midnight-style presentations of The Rocky Horror Picture Show, accompanied by the Crazed Imaginations shadow cast, remain a fixture of the theater's programming.

Despite the uncertainty surrounding its future, La Paloma continues operating normally. Its published schedule includes screenings and special events throughout November and December, with tickets available for upcoming presentations.

For now, the reported escrow transaction remains an allegation rather than an established sale. The identity of any prospective purchaser, the status of the property's ownership, and the intentions of those involved have yet to be confirmed.

What the petition has accomplished is to bring renewed attention to the future of one of Encinitas' most recognizable historic landmarks, nearly a century after its marquee first illuminated Coast Highway 101.

La Paloma Theatre is located at 471 South Coast Highway 101 in Encinitas. For more information, visit lapalomatheatre.com.

Originally published on November 16, 2026.