▼

San Diego's Historic Old Spaghetti Factory Ordered Temporarily Closed By Health Inspectors Over Vermin And Sewage Disposal Issues

One of San Diego's oldest and most recognizable downtown restaurants received an unwelcome visit from county health inspectors this week, resulting in an immediate closure over vermin, water and sewage violations. But just 24 hours later, The Old Spaghetti Factory in the Gaslamp Quarter was back in business, having secured permission to reopen and earned a perfect 100-point health inspection score.

The Old Spaghetti Factory, which has occupied its historic building at 275 Fifth Avenue since 1974, was ordered closed on Monday, November 16, after a routine inspection by the San Diego County Department of Environmental Health and Quality identified three violations, including two classified as major.

According to county inspection records, inspectors documented a major vermin violation, a major violation involving hot and cold water, and a minor sewage-disposal violation. The findings were serious enough to warrant an immediate shutdown of the restaurant, a longtime fixture of the Gaslamp Quarter that has served generations of San Diegans and visitors over more than five decades.

The county's publicly available inspection summary does not identify the specific type of vermin involved, the extent of the infestation or the exact nature of the water and sewage problems. A major vermin violation can involve evidence of rodents, cockroaches or other pests under California's food safety regulations, but the inspection summary does not establish which were found at this location.

The turnaround, however, was unusually swift.

On Tuesday, November 17, county inspectors returned to the restaurant for a reinspection and approved it to reopen, listing no violations. A separate routine inspection conducted that same day also found no violations, awarding The Old Spaghetti Factory a score of 100 and an A grade.

The restaurant therefore went from being ordered closed for major health violations to receiving a perfect inspection score the very next day.

The county records do not detail the corrective measures undertaken between inspections, although approval to reopen indicates that inspectors determined the conditions preventing the restaurant from operating had been sufficiently addressed.

The November closure stands out against the restaurant's recent inspection history. Its previous routine inspection, conducted May 12, 2026, resulted in a perfect 100-point score and an A grade, with no violations recorded. An environmental inspection on September 18 also found no violations.

Earlier routine inspections were generally favorable, although not entirely without deficiencies. In March 2025, the restaurant received a 97-point A grade after inspectors noted minor issues involving food-contact surfaces and cleanliness of nonfood-contact surfaces. A May 2024 inspection resulted in a 98-point A grade, while a May 2023 inspection produced a 94-point A grade following findings involving food-contact surfaces, hot and cold water, cleanliness and ventilation.

None of those earlier inspections in the records reviewed resulted in closure.

The temporary shutdown is particularly notable given The Old Spaghetti Factory's place in San Diego's restaurant history. Long before the Gaslamp Quarter became a bustling destination filled with rooftop bars, nightclubs, upscale restaurants and convention visitors, the Italian-American chain was helping bring diners back to a downtown neighborhood that many San Diegans had largely abandoned.

The restaurant opened on February 20, 1974, inside a Victorian-era commercial building constructed in 1898 near the corner of Fifth Avenue and K Street. Its arrival came at a pivotal moment for downtown San Diego, when the area now known as the Gaslamp Quarter was still struggling with deteriorating buildings, vacant storefronts and a reputation far removed from its present-day status as an entertainment district.

The Old Spaghetti Factory was among the early businesses to embrace the neighborhood's historic architecture rather than demolish it, helping demonstrate the commercial potential of restoring old downtown buildings for new uses.

The structure, historically associated with the Buel-Town Company Building, was designed by prominent San Diego architects William Sterling Hebbard and Irving Gill, whose early work helped shape the city's architectural identity. Its distinctive brick façade, arched windows and ornate Victorian details provided an ideal backdrop for a restaurant chain built around antique furnishings and nostalgic interiors.

Founded in Portland, Oregon, in 1969 by Guss and Sally Dussin, The Old Spaghetti Factory developed a formula that was as much about atmosphere as it was about pasta. Its restaurants became known for stained-glass lighting, antique décor, upholstered booths, vintage furnishings and, most famously, full-size trolley cars repurposed as dining rooms.

The San Diego location incorporated that same eccentric aesthetic, including a trolley car that became a favorite dining spot for families and children.

For generations of local residents, the restaurant was a dependable destination for birthday dinners, family celebrations and inexpensive nights out. Its menu of Italian-American comfort food, including spaghetti with Mizithra cheese and browned butter, lasagna, meatballs and spumoni ice cream, became familiar to customers who returned year after year.

The restaurant also became a popular gathering place during Comic-Con and other major downtown events, offering an approachable alternative to the Gaslamp Quarter's increasingly expensive dining scene.

Its longevity is especially remarkable considering how dramatically the surrounding neighborhood has changed.

When The Old Spaghetti Factory opened, the modern Gaslamp Quarter was still largely an idea being championed by civic leaders and property owners who envisioned restoring downtown's historic buildings and attracting new businesses. The restaurant's success helped validate that vision, and it eventually became one of the district's best-known early dining establishments.

But even The Old Spaghetti Factory was not immune to changing tastes.

In the mid-2000s, as the Gaslamp Quarter increasingly embraced upscale dining and nightlife, the company replaced its longstanding San Diego restaurant with Dussini Mediterranean Bistro, a more ambitious concept named in honor of the founding Dussin family.

The restaurant introduced a higher-end Mediterranean menu and a more contemporary dining experience, departing from the affordable pasta dinners that had defined the location for decades.

The experiment ultimately proved short-lived.

By 2009, The Old Spaghetti Factory had returned to the Fifth Avenue building, restoring its familiar menu and much of the atmosphere that longtime customers remembered. The comeback was welcomed by patrons who had missed the restaurant's accessible prices, generous portions and nostalgic dining experience.

Since then, the establishment has continued operating through multiple waves of downtown redevelopment, the rise of celebrity-chef restaurants, the COVID-19 pandemic and an increasingly competitive dining market that has seen numerous longtime Gaslamp businesses disappear.

Today, The Old Spaghetti Factory remains one of the Gaslamp Quarter's longest-running restaurants and a reminder of the neighborhood's early revitalization, occupying a historic building that has stood for more than 125 years.

That history makes this week's health department closure an especially striking development. A restaurant that helped pioneer downtown San Diego's restaurant revival more than half a century ago was temporarily sidelined by violations involving some of the most fundamental aspects of food safety: pest control, water and sewage disposal.

The county's major violation classifications indicate that inspectors identified conditions warranting immediate corrective action, although the publicly available summary does not provide enough detail to determine the severity or duration of the underlying problems.

Still, the restaurant's rapid reopening and subsequent perfect inspection score suggest that whatever conditions prompted the shutdown were addressed to the satisfaction of county inspectors by the following day.

For now, The Old Spaghetti Factory is once again permitted to serve its familiar pasta dinners in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter, adding an unusual one-day closure to a downtown dining history stretching back to 1974.

The Old Spaghetti Factory is located at 275 Fifth Avenue in San Diego's Gaslamp Quarter. For more information, visit osf.com. 

Originally published on November 18, 2026.