▼

Josie's Diner Makes A Messy First Impression In San Diego's Hillcrest As Owner's French Bulldog Leaves "Her Mark" On Brand New Restaurant

San Diego's newest diner has barely opened its doors, and the namesake four-legged member of the ownership family has already left an unforgettable impression. Josie's, the nostalgic American restaurant that recently debuted in Hillcrest after eight years of vacancy, found itself at the center of an unusual opening-weekend incident involving a French bulldog, an unfortunate bathroom accident and a question that has become increasingly relevant as San Diego's dining scene grows more dog-friendly: just where are pets actually allowed inside restaurants?

Josie's opened November 12 at 1270 Cleveland Avenue in The Hub Hillcrest, bringing new life to the former Panera Bread space. But during its first weekend, images and reports shared with SanDiegoVille appeared to show a French bulldog relieving herself at the establishment, prompting questions about the dog's ownership and whether she was permitted inside.

As it turns out, the dog belongs to Josie's co-owner Matthew Sieve, and her name is Josie. Yes, the restaurant's namesake apparently wasted little time making her mark.

Sieve confirmed to SanDiegoVille that Josie is his dog and is not a service animal. He explained that he lives in the residential complex attached to the restaurant and regularly passes the establishment while walking her.

"She was briefly inside the restaurant during that visit, but the accident occurred on the rug immediately outside the front door," Sieve initially wrote in response to questions from SanDiegoVille.

The individual who supplied the images, however, maintained that the dog was off leash and defecated both inside and outside the establishment.

"Josie was off leash," the customer said in a message to SanDiegoVille. "The poop picture I sent you was on the inside. To be fair, I didn't see the outside rug...maybe it was mostly there."
In subsequent correspondence, Sieve acknowledged that at least part of the incident occurred inside the restaurant's entrance.

"Yes, from what I remember, it happened just inside the front entrance," Sieve clarified. "I usually carry Josie out, and she immediately squatted when I set her down by the door. She's a special-needs Frenchie, and it was an unfortunate accident."

Sieve explained that Josie has short-spine syndrome, a medical condition that can affect a dog's spinal development, and occasionally experiences incontinence.

"I understand why the incident raised a concern, and I take my responsibility to maintain a clean and sanitary environment seriously," Sieve stated.

According to Sieve, the affected rug was discarded, and other affected areas were cleaned and sanitized.

"The rug was discarded, and the other affected areas were cleaned and sanitized. Going forward, I will keep Josie outside the restaurant during our walks," he said.

Sieve also expressed concern that the incident could overshadow the work involved in opening the restaurant.

"I get the 'leaving her mark' line, but I'd hate for that moment to overshadow the opening and all the work the team has put into the restaurant," he wrote.

The incident may have been an unfortunate accident involving a dog with a medical condition, but it also raises a legitimate food safety issue that applies to restaurants throughout California.

Under California Health and Safety Code Section 114259.5, live animals are generally prohibited inside food establishments, subject to specific exceptions. Qualifying service animals are permitted in public dining areas, provided their presence does not create a health or safety hazard, while ordinary pets generally cannot accompany their owners into enclosed restaurant dining rooms.

The prohibition applies to restaurant owners and employees as well as customers. Simply owning the business does not create an exemption allowing someone to bring a personal pet inside.
Matt & Josie, image take from screenshot of San Diego Magazine First Look video. 
California does, however, allow restaurants to welcome pet dogs in outdoor dining areas when certain conditions are met. The restaurant must choose to permit them, dogs must enter through a separate outdoor entrance without passing through the interior, and they must remain leashed or otherwise properly confined and under their owners' control.

Dogs are not permitted on chairs, benches or other seating fixtures, and employees must follow sanitation requirements when interacting with animals.

The law specifically requires outdoor dining areas to be kept clean and surfaces contaminated by animal waste or other bodily fluids to be cleaned and sanitized.

Federal law provides additional protections for people who rely on trained service animals. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act, qualifying service dogs generally must be admitted to areas open to customers, even where ordinary pets are prohibited.

Emotional support animals and household pets do not receive the same automatic public-access protections under the ADA. Businesses may also require removal of a service animal that is not housebroken or is out of control and whose handler fails to regain control.

Josie's medical condition may explain the accident, but it does not provide a legal exception to California's rules governing pets inside restaurants.

The issue has become increasingly visible in San Diego, where restaurants, breweries, coffee shops and neighborhood patios frequently market themselves as dog-friendly. The city's outdoor-oriented dining culture has made bringing dogs along for a meal commonplace, particularly in neighborhoods such as North Park, Hillcrest, Pacific Beach and Little Italy.

Still, a dog-friendly patio and an indoor dining room are governed by different rules, and the popularity of dining with pets has not eliminated the sanitation requirements intended to protect customers and food preparation areas.

For Josie's, the opening-weekend mishap comes at an otherwise significant moment for Sieve and business partner Jeffrey Fink, whose restaurant group also currently operates Madi locations in University Heights and Pacific Beach and Sonny's Pizza in University Heights.

The partners spent approximately $1.5 million transforming the former Panera Bread space into a roughly 175-seat diner featuring burgundy booths, chrome counter stools, a nostalgic photo booth and a design intended to evoke traditional American restaurants.
The restaurant takes inspiration from Sieve's Minnesota upbringing and his family's century-old Travelers Inn Cafe, which opened in Alexandria, Minnesota, in 1925. The new Hillcrest concept is named in honor of his great-aunt Josie, adding another family connection to a business that now shares its name with his French bulldog.

Although Josie's debuted with breakfast and lunch service, Sieve has now confirmed that the restaurant is preparing to introduce dinner service during the week of November 23, with a significantly different menu and atmosphere.

"Dinner opens next week," Sieve told SanDiegoVille, describing plans for "more upscale supper-club vibes" and a different evening menu.

The restaurant's public relations team is preparing a formal announcement introducing the dinner program and highlighting its culinary leadership. Sieve said the team has recently completed new food photography and is preparing to share additional details about Chef Angela, who is involved in the restaurant's next phase.

The expansion is intended to give Josie's a second identity after dark, transforming the daytime diner into a more intimate evening destination with an elevated menu.

The restaurant is also part of a broader period of transition for Sieve and Fink, who recently closed their longtime University Heights restaurant Madison on Park to prepare the property for an entirely new concept.

Madison served its final customers September 6 after more than a decade at 4622 Park Boulevard. Rather than relinquish the property, the partners announced plans to substantially renovate the space and introduce a different restaurant intended to attract a broader mix of customers throughout the week.

Sieve has now provided additional insight into the replacement, explaining that Fink is taking the lead on the project while he concentrates on launching Josie's.

"My understanding is that the direction is a small-plates spot with a European café feel and a warm, contemporary atmosphere," Sieve told SanDiegoVille.

According to Sieve, Fink spent time in Spain with his family over the summer and has been drawing inspiration from that experience as the new restaurant takes shape.

The concept has not yet secured a final name or chef, although Sieve said the partners are considering incorporating the word "Bar" into the restaurant's name.

Sieve also confirmed that designers Anna and David Sindelar, who helped shape Madison's original appearance, have been involved in the early design work. He viewed preliminary renderings several months ago but has not yet seen the latest plans.

"My one request was plenty of warm, amber lighting throughout the space," Sieve joked.

The proposed restaurant had previously been compared by one source to North Park's Part Time Lover, the cocktail lounge and high-fidelity listening bar known for its carefully curated music and vintage-inspired atmosphere. However, Sieve cautioned that the comparison does not necessarily reflect the designs he has seen.

"Jeff would be better positioned to say whether the Part Time Lover comparison fits but that's not really what I saw in the renderings," he explained.

While the replacement is expected to feature a contemporary European café atmosphere, there has been no confirmation that it will incorporate a listening-bar component, vinyl programming or a similar music-focused format.

The opening timetable also remains fluid. Although the owners initially anticipated reopening the University Heights space as early as October, Sieve said the most recent target he had heard was New Year's Eve.

"The last opening target I heard was New Year's Eve, but I expect that could move a couple of months into the new year," he stated. "I don't have a confirmed date to share yet."

That would place the potential opening sometime in early 2027, depending on the completion of design work, renovations and other preparations.

Meanwhile, Josie's is now welcoming customers in Hillcrest, where the former Panera Bread storefront had sat vacant since 2018. With dinner service approaching and a new University Heights restaurant in development, Sieve and Fink are entering a particularly busy period for their growing hospitality business.

And while Josie's opening weekend may have produced an unexpected sanitation concern, Sieve's response indicates that the owner recognizes the issue and intends to prevent another incident.

As for Josie herself, the French bulldog may have already earned a place in the restaurant's opening-weekend history, even if her future visits will be limited to the sidewalk.

Josie's is located at 1270 Cleveland Avenue, Suite K, in The Hub Hillcrest shopping center in San Diego. For additional information, visit dearjosies.com.

Originally published on November 17, 2026.